Welcome To The ByLaw, A Perfect Legal Solution.

BIA Rules Asylum Claims From EU and Other Safe-Country Nationals Should Generally Be Denied

On October 9, 2026, the Board of Immigration Appeals published an unprecedented ruling that establishes a restrictive presumption affecting asylum applicants from 40 specifically identified countries. In Matter of B-S-A-N-, 30 I&N Dec. 145 (BIA 2026), the Board told Immigration Judges to deny asylum claims from nationals of highly developed democracies as a general rule barring some exceptional circumstance. This decision included every European Union country, plus the U.K., Canada, Japan, and several others.

The decision marks a significant change in U.S. asylum law. If you or a loved one holds citizenship in one of these countries, consult with a lawyer to determine whether your case has been affected by the recent developments.

What the BIA Decided in Matter of B-S-A-N-

The case involved a woman who holds citizenship in both France and Gabon. She came to the U.S. on a student visa in 2016, filed for asylum in 2018 based on her family’s political activities, and said that she feared returning to France as Gabonese agents could find and hurt her there as well.

It is a long-standing requirement that a dual national show a well-founded fear of persecution in each country in which they hold citizenship. Matter of B-R-, 26 I&N Dec. 119 (BIA 2013). The Board in B-S-A-N-, as it has before, found insufficient objective evidence that she would face persecution in France.

However, what renders this decision out of the ordinary is that the Board didn’t stop there. Instead, they opted to make a larger decision outside of the case being argued and issue a precedential decision binding Immigration Judges nationwide regarding countries that had nothing to do with the case presented before them by Ms. B-S-A-N-. Specifically, B-S-A-N- has set two broad rules that did not exist before:

  1. The safe-country rule: Judges should generally deny asylum to nationals of developed democracies that broadly respect and protect human rights.
  2. The EU discretion rule: EU citizens are presumed ineligible for a discretionary grant of asylum because they can legally live in any other EU member state.

 

You can read the full decision on the U.S. Department of Justice website. It goes without saying that these rules can be contested and very well could be appealed by Ms. B-S-A-N- due to the Board’s arguably improper issuance of an advisory opinion that goes beyond what was in front of them for decision in B-S-A-N- as well as the fact that the INA itself calls for individualized refugee determination rather than a nationality-based presumption. 8 U.S.C. § 1158(b)(1)(A). As of October 20, 2026 we are not aware of any Federal Court challenges in the Fourth Circuit contesting this new rule nor are we aware of any such challenges in other Circuits. As such, these rules represent the law as it is now and must be complied with in front of Immigration Judges unless and until they are overturned by a higher court. You are not precluded from arguing that the rule is wrong before the Immigration Judge, in fact you must do so if you wish to preserve it for appeal, but the judge is bound to apply the law as it is for the time being.

Which Countries Are Covered

The Board explicitly named 40 countries that have a presumption of asylum ineligibility. It based this decision on the unilateral finding, without the opportunity to present evidence to the contrary on the record, that they all have strong human rights protections and fair courts, and that the list could change as conditions change both in the 40 named countries and in other countries that may potentially be added. The Board did so by taking administrative notice of the relative safety pursuant to 8 C.F.R. § 1003.1(d)(3)(iv) despite the contestability of such a claim.

The following countries are those explicitly mentioned by the Board in B-S-A-N-:

EU Member States

All 27 EU countries are covered: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czechia, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, and Sweden.

When it comes to asylum, EU citizens now face two hurdles instead of one. Under EU free movement law, EU citizens have broad rights to move and reside in other member states, subject to applicable residence requirements. The Board treated those rights as a ready-made haven. So even if an EU citizen proves a real fear of persecution at home, they’d still need to show they can’t safely live anywhere else in the bloc to obtain discretionary relief. The European Commission explains these residence rights on its free movement and residence page.

Other Countries on the List

Group Countries
EEA and EFTA partners Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway, Switzerland
European microstates Monaco, Andorra, San Marino
Other developed democracies United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, South Korea

Dual nationals should pay close attention here. Dual nationals must generally establish that they cannot obtain protection in each country of nationality. Citizenship in a country identified by the Board may therefore create a substantial obstacle, even when the harm you fear is tied to your other country of origin.

Concerned about how this ruling affects your case? The asylum attorneys at Fayad Law can review your situation and walk you through your options. Call (703) 998-5390 to schedule a consultation.

What the Decision Means for Asylum, Withholding of Removal, and CAT Claims

The Board extended its “safe-country” holding to withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) as well, making it more difficult across the board for nationals of the 40 “safe” countries to obtain fear-based relief here in the United States. These protections have distinct legal requirements, though the Board relied on their higher harm thresholds and, for CAT, its official-involvement requirement to deny them as well.

This represents a significant shift. Withholding and CAT have long served as a backstop for people who can’t get asylum for one reason or another since judges cannot deny them as a matter of discretion. This part of the ruling will likely also face federal-court challenges, but as before we must operate at the lower court level under the assumption that it applies. The decision remains binding on Immigration Judges unless controlling legal authority modifies or overturns it, which is why anyone with pending asylum cases involving a listed country should revisit their strategy with counsel.

The Board expressly disagreed with the Ninth Circuit’s disfavored-group analysis discussed in Lapadat v. Bondi (2025), highlighting a potential conflict between the Board’s approach and existing circuit precedent and providing possible avenues to challenge this harsh new rule.

Immediate Implications After B-S-A-N-

The Immigration Court has access to a tool known as pretermission to deal with cases that are deemed unable to succeed on the merits. Pretermission allows an Immigration Judge to deny an application without a full evidentiary hearing when the application fails to establish prima facie eligibility for relief. Under Matter of H-A-A-V- (2025), a case may be pretermitted when an application doesn’t show basic eligibility on its face. A September 2026 decision, Matter of G-R-B-, added that judges can pretermit cases even if DHS never files a motion requesting it. This does not mean that every applicant from a listed country will automatically be denied a hearing or have their case denied without the opportunity to present evidence, but it does mean that extra care and effort must be taken to ensure that your case does not get prematurely denied due to the change in law.

Matter of B-S-A-N- explicitly says that pretermission applies to “safe-country” nationals as a general rule, and that such pretermission would usually occur at the master calendar hearing. That’s the short first hearing in a case, so a claim could end before the applicant ever testifies or is given the opportunity to present documentary evidence.

Because of that, the written record carries far more weight now and the need to provide documentary evidence beyond just the application itself has increased dramatically. Things that tend to strengthen a file include:

  • A detailed personal declaration filed with Form I-589
  • Country conditions evidence tied to your specific situation or group
  • For EU citizens, proof of why moving elsewhere in the EU isn’t an available option for you
  • Written legal arguments submitted before the master calendar hearing

Exceptions: National Security and Foreign Policy

The Board identified extraordinary national security or foreign policy considerations as exceptions to its general safe-country approach and grounds for overcoming the EU discretionary presumption. The decision doesn’t define what that looks like in practice.

What’s notably missing is an exception for individuals who can document serious personal risk, like LGBTQ+ or Roma applicants from listed countries. The Board did say evidence in individual cases may support adding or removing a country from the list. The Board acknowledged that significant changes in country conditions, supported by evidence, may justify reconsidering whether a country belongs in the safe-country category.

Who Is Not Affected by This Decision

The ruling is broad, but it doesn’t reach:

  • Nationals of countries that aren’t on the list. Their claims follow the usual legal standards.
  • Other forms of relief. Cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, U visas, T visas, and VAWA petitions operate under their own rules.
  • The legal definition of a refugee. That standard under the Immigration and Nationality Act hasn’t changed.

What to Watch Next: Other Residence Agreements and Changes to the Country List

A footnote in the decision hints at where things could head. The Board said judges may also weigh other residence agreements, naming the Mercosur Residence Agreement covering certain South American countries and the Trans-Tasman Travel Arrangement between Australia and New Zealand. Similar residence arrangements could matter when judges assess whether applicants have access to protection elsewhere.

A few developments are worth tracking:

  • Federal court challenges, especially in the Fourth Circuit and the Ninth Circuit where Lapadat remains binding precedent.
  • Countries added to or removed from the list as conditions change.
  • How often judges pretermit asylum application filings at early hearings

Connect to an Asylum Attorney About Your Case

This ruling raises the stakes for anyone with ties to a listed country. Every case turns on its own facts, so it helps to have someone review yours closely. Fayad Law represents asylum applicants in Immigration Court and before the BIA. Call (703) 998-5390 to talk with our team about your situation.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog post is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this post does not create an attorney-client relationship. Immigration laws and USCIS procedures change frequently; please consult with a qualified immigration attorney regarding your specific case.

Tags:

News & blog updates

Related Post